Faux Blacks Eyeliner Pencil - Onyx (Black With Multi Colored Glitter)

Although I love the color and that it lasts all day, I have to be honest and say that I have to sharpen the pencil after every use because it wears down to the wood and it scratches your skin. It’s crazy … it just doesn’t get dull at the end … you literally feel the wood at the end. I’d still buy it though because I love the color. They’re inexpensive so I bought 6 of them last time.

I stumbled upon this eyeliner one day in a department store and have loved it enough that I purchase it online now to get it's not available in any stores near me. My color choice is Black Hole. The purple tint is just enough to catch your attention while maintaining a true black classic look. The only downfall is that it needs to be sharpened often (like every other use). But it's a long pencil so I feel you get your money's worth. Definitely I invest in a good sharpener if you don't have one. This type of pencil needs a good one. Urban decay sells one for about 10.00 and it lasts for years.

Someone posted about this color enhances green eyes so I figured I would give it a shot since I liked their other eye liners and I wasn’t disappointed at all. It’s a great alternative to strictly black or brown eyeliners if you are wanting to wear it for work. It gets better throughout the day and doesn’t leave me looking like a sad panda.

I received this product on January 2, 2024 and by January 5th the product was gone. The product tip was so tiny that there was less than a week of product to use and no way to sharpen or get more product out of pencil shaft. Then, after consulting several friends more savvy on various cosmetics than me, I discovered you needed a pencil sharpener to access the rest of the product. The description never said that nor have I ever had an eye-pencil previously that did not contain the sharpener in the product lid or had a auto-fill feature. Disappointed in this particular product for this reason so be aware if you choose to purchase it.

Love this color with my brown eyes. It stays on all day and is waterproof. Just need to sharpen it to keep the tip thin, I cant find anything else like this, glad Amazon has it on Prime💖

I can't believe this line of eyeliners was discontinued by NYX, they are my favorite and I haven't found an exact color replacement yet.

Love this color for autumn / Winter !! It's perfect. Goes on smooth and stays.

The color of this Eyeliner pencil is a beautiful red/brown color, and I really like it BUT... The pencil does NOT TWIST UP! It is a "plastic" pencil, that is VERY DIFFICULT to sharpen. The liner part of the pencil is extremely soft and breaks off after being sharpened, thus it needs to be sharpened again, and I am sure it is not going to last very long at that rate!! I bought this color, and another color. I have not used the other color yet, but I anticipate the same issue with it. I am very disappointed in the NYX brand. I thought their products were better quality than this. Wil not be purchasing eyeliner from NYX again.