- Eyeliner Pencil, 1440 Longwear Green Eyeliner Pencil - Waterproof, Sharpenable & Smudge Proof (Olive)

This eyeliner is very black and goes on smoothly without tugging on the skin. It’s easy to apply, even along the lash line, and gives a clean, defined look. Once it sets, it really stays put — it doesn’t smudge or fade throughout the day. I like that it’s waterproof but still comfortable to wear. It sharpens well and doesn’t crumble. Great everyday eyeliner if you want something reliable that lasts from morning to night.

This eyeliner pencil is great. The color is intense, it glides on easily, and it truly lasts for hours without smudging. I wore it all day and it stayed in place. Perfect for everyday use and long wear.

I’ve been using this eyeliner regularly and love how deep and rich the black color is. It glides on smoothly without tugging and gives a clean, precise line. Once set, it stays put most of the day with minimal smudging, even around the waterline. The pencil sharpens well and doesn’t crumble. Great option for everyday wear or a more defined look.

I genuinely love this product! I enjoy applying it along my waterline and between my lashes. Using a small brush, I gently sweep over my lashes to perfect any imperfections, resulting in lashes that appear longer and thicker. I’m completely sold on this because it never smudges or feels gooey in the corners of my eyes. Mixing two of their shades creates a unique, long-lasting look! While I don’t use it as a classic eyeliner, I do draw a tiny line in the center of my eye and blend it out with a small brush for a subtle effect. With dark brown eyes, the darker green and deep brown shades really make my eyes pop. I’ve also found I don’t need mascara or eyeshadow, as this product enhances my natural eye color beautifully.

I'm 65. I look ok for my age. I've worn makeup every day since i'm 12 years old! I have been using pencil eyeliner for that long. This product is great! At first, I was upset I broke the point off immediately. That's because all other pencils are hard & pull terribly on my lid. But this is so soft & malleable that I'm so impressed. I love this product. Goes on so easy.....no pressure! And it STAYS ON!!!! I can wear it to sleep!!! I never wrote a review. Ever. I am truly impressed. Always buying this pencil from now on...... :)

I have a love-hate relationship with this eyeliner. I love the rich colors. I love how smoothly it goes on, especially given the tender sensitive skin around my aging eyes. I like the thick lines that I can create effortlessly. In contrast to some reviews, I've never had any trouble sharpening these pencils with a drugstore eyeliner sharpener. My problem is that the color stays in spots but not in others, resulting in an uneven appearance within a couple hours of application. It smudges, drifts, and disappears. I don't know what the problem is, but the outer edges of my eyes, where I want the color the most, end up without color the fastest. Is it my watery allergy eyes? Do I touch the outer eye somehow when I'm placing and removing my eyeglasses? I don't know. I end up disappointed, though, which makes the cost of these pencils feel too high.

Wonderskin is seriously 50/50 for me. I've gotten a few products that are exactly how they seem, and then mostly they are awful somehow so I was reluctant to try this but I'm always looking for long wear smudge proof eyeliner b/c my eyes water like crazy. To be clear, my go to holy grail is Maybelline New York unstoppable eyeliner pencil the twist up one. I have it in almost every color and it is incredible, never smudging stays on forever. The only reason I'm not the biggest fan of it is that it doesn't always glide on how I want my eyeliner to. I saw this one glides on real well, and I thought maybe it was worth giving it a go despite my dislikes with this brand. I was wrong. It GLOBS on. Even when I refrigerate it so it's not too warm. It clumps all over my eyes and lashes. I used cotton swabs to try to fix it. It DOES smoke out real nicely, but it also smudges pretty bad. It stays where you put it, but it also gets everywhere. Especially if it's clumping. HERE'S THE WORST PART THO. while it did last all day long (I still had it mostly intact where I applied it through my 8 hour shift, after work drinks, making dinner, all night until I washed my face before bed), it also started flaking really badly in hard chunks after my work day. I was constantly getting big hard flakes on my eyeball and it hurt. It was coming off in hard chunks and leaving bare spots where it lifted. I haven't had something like that happen since I was in middle school in 1998 and bought the worst quality liquid liner you could ever imagine at a dollar store because that's all I could afford. So that's my closest comparison, decades old memories of horrible dollar store makeup. I'm not about this and I don't think it's worth trying even if it's on sale.

I haven't felt compelled to review a beauty product in a long time and this eyeliner has broken that streak. I bought this eyeliner in Licorice. I'm incredibly surprised that it not only stayed on but is actually pretty waterproof and smudgeproof as advertised. The picture I've attached is after over NINE hours of wear and this is including several episodes of crying over strangers on the Internet after they received the help and kindness they deserved. I was wary of this item because I prefer liquid liners and, despite having tried many types of both liquid and pencil eyeliners that claimed to be waterproof and/or smudgeproof, I always end up looking like a raccoon. If I wore eyeliner, I had to use setting powder to prevent smudging to my upper lid. I actually stopped wearing eyeliner because of the inconvenience and uncertainty. I didn't wear anything with this eyeliner and it never transferred. It has a deep, rich color to it and I do think you need to let it "set" a bit by not touching the newly drawn line for 30 seconds or so. I made a mistake while applying and I was able to wipe it off immediately. Very impressed with this product. My only wish was that the pencil didn't require sharpening and my hope is that this isn't a first-time fluke.