When Pencil Met Gel Sharpenable Multi-Use Longwear Eyeliner Pencil - Camo Green Matte - Transfer-Proof - High Performance Liner

I really like the color of this pencil and it goes on easily. Stays where I apply it. Good product.

Great color, truly waterproof and long lasting. Smooth texture for tight lining older eye area. A winner and would use other colors.

I love the color, Rich Brown matte. It does apply very easily and evenly IF you keep your pencil sharpened. You have to purchase a special, more expensive sharpener or it doesn't sharpen well at all. It does smudge but it is the best I've found since the wooden pencil product that I used to use is no longer available since that company went out of business. I have been to multiple stores trying to find a wooden pencil with this rich color (because they last a lot longer than these plastic ones) but I was told that most brands have switched to this type. I did buy multiple just in case this is no longer available. Only caveat, make sure it is sharpened long enough so the plastic doesn't scratch your eyelid.

Excellent liner. Stays putand does not bleed. I use it for my water lineand after 8 hours of wear it was still in place. Considering I've spent far more on liners that did not work at all, I would say this is the best I've tried.

Beautiful color. Smooth application. Slight sting to the eye in the waterline. Super sexy, makes Eyes 👀 pop.

Normally I qear Eye of Horus eyeliner I get from Beauty and the Boutique in England. But with the high tariffs, it's not practical anymore. This is a dupe for one of the brown eyeliners I wear. It stays on, lasts all day and doesn't smudge once it sets. I find it's okay with my allergy, sensitive eyes. It has a creamy texture that can be smudged before it sets.

I hope this would be a cool dark brown. It swatched that way, but upon wearing just under an hour it was like the color faded?? It was just grayish. I was wearing it alone, so no idea how that happened. It didn't want to glide on my waterline. It was a fight to get it to stay. And when it did finally, the feeling on my eyes was really heavy and sticky. Every blink feels like the stickiest lip gloss idk how else to describe it. I was considering trying a different color, but the way this feels on my eyes I can't justify it. Besides that though, no irritation, which was nice. I have sensitive eyes and it didn't bother my eyes like that at all. And, it seemed to have some staying power. It didn't smudge or transfer much at all, and it stayed where I put it.

Suprisingly good eyeliner! Glides on, has staying power, and good color pigmentation. I usually either use eyeshadow on my eyeliner to set it, or set it with a setting spray (or both), and I have not experienced smudging or flaking. My only complaint is that it does not sharpen to a fine point even using the Julep sharpener, but that's not a deal breaker for me.

The best makeup pencil sharpener I’ve ever owned. I have tried so many and they have been rubbish! Tired of buying multiple sharpeners I decided to invest in this one and I have no regrets. It sharpens both larger and smaller lip liner pencils. Great item and fab quality great travel size.

Je ne l’ai pas encore utilisé mais sa couleur est bien celle que je souhaitais.

Very soft to apply and a flattering deep violet colour which brings out my mid-brown eye colour.

The shade terracotta matte is beautiful. It’s such an easy, natural looking eyeliner if you want a bit of definition, but nothing too harsh, as I have very pale skin, and even brown can look too intense for me sometimes. It’s a really great eyeliner for a day look. So easy to pop on, it’s really creamy, and doesn’t go on dry and skippy at all, so I’d say it’s just as good as any of the more expensive brands. You can blend it too before it sets. It stays put brilliantly, it lasts all day! And I have very oily eyelids. I also find it really easy to remove, just by washing my face. I have powered through the pencil quite quickly due to sharpening it, I would love this eyeliner in a retractable format. I haven’t found I’ve experienced any eye irritation at all with these. Brilliant eyeliner! So easy to use for a quick, no fuss, eye makeup look, so it’s very functional for someone like me that doesn’t want to fuss over makeup application for hours.

Finally I found the perfect sharpener for my eyeliner. It doesn’t ruin my kohl eyeliners.