Hot Cocoa Professional Ultra Fine Eyeliner Pencil, Creamy, Ultra-pigmented, Long-lasting, Creates Defined Lines,Professional Makeup, Set of 3, Italia

I do love this shade, it is a med/dark brown with warm chocolate tones and a tinge of red. It is the tinge of red I was looking for because for cinnamon brown eyes as a liner, it makes the eyes really spark.This is a perfect shade for us. I use it on my waterline and had no allergic response of sensitivity and I'm very sensitive to everything.I also used it to fill in my eyebrows, the eyes and eyebrow matching is quite a perk.A reviewer commented about the red tinge and that is why I bought it and I am glad.The consistency is highly pigmented and creamy so it goes on smooth. It did not smudge, and I had no allergic response to it, as I do to some red pigments in eyeliners. The price is right for just one pencil in my opinion because it checks all my boxes for color, non allergic, and non smudge, and ease of application, but then you get three pencils.These are not made in Italy nor are Italian. They are made in China.This is still a deal. I recommend while it is still available!

I have been looking for a very long time for the right color blue eye pencil as this is the only color I have worn for years. Use to get them from Cover Girl but they do not make them anymore. I can’t begin to tell you how many I have bought over the past year and threw out because they were not good. As I was browsing I saw these and decided why not try. Well to my surprise these are Great. The color is perfect the color glides on easily and I got 3 pencils for like $5.00. Such a deal. One happy lady!!!

First of all, that price?!? You can’t beat it. The pencils come pre sharpened so that’s amazing! This color is beautiful on my medium skin tone, I’d say it’s the perfect mix of NYX’s Cold Brew and KVD’s Crucifix. They’re fairly long pencils so they might have to squeeze in little makeup pouches! I wouldn’t say they’re smudge proof but that doesn’t bother me. You can’t go wrong with this three pack, it’s my new lip combo!

Nice product. It is easy to apply… it glides on! Unfortunately, royal blue isn’t quite the color. To me, it’s a bright (borderline neon) cobalt blue. It’s a very fun color, but on a 56 year old…. Hmmmmm, not so sure.

i absolutely love these pencils! the color looks great on me and it lasts a good while.

I use them for my eyes and love the product it goes on smooth and stays on. I was sent the wrong color.

This is a Mac chestnut dupe. I’ve worn that color for years and this is a good alternative. This is affordable as well.I will say that it’s not long lasting. It comes off quite easily, but it’s also not advertised as waterproof or anything so that’s to be expected.

This product works amazing And looks amazing comes with many lip liners